41
19
5
等級4
2.1K
18
牛一vs牛陣vs牛涮鍋
2018-05-03 9422 瀏覽
We were frequent visitors to 牛陣 and had recently visited 牛涮鍋. Finally we also visited this 牛一 in the same district.We ordered the most expensive 90-min lunch set of Japanese Wagyu beef and pork at $248 + 10%. We asked for 2 portions of Wagyu and no to pork as soon as we had placed our orders but they still served us pork.The first round of Japanese Wagyu beef was very tender and yummy, although it still seemed to be worse than those at 牛涮鍋 which seemed to be bigger yet also tender but was more e
更多
We were frequent visitors to 牛陣 and had recently visited 牛涮鍋. Finally we also visited this 牛一 in the same district.

1471 瀏覽
1 讚好
0 留言
 We ordered the most expensive 90-min lunch set of Japanese Wagyu beef and pork at $248 + 10%. We asked for 2 portions of Wagyu and no to pork as soon as we had placed our orders but they still served us pork.

First round of Japanese Wagyu Beef
296 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 The first round of Japanese Wagyu beef was very tender and yummy, although it still seemed to be worse than those at 牛涮鍋 which seemed to be bigger yet also tender but was more expensive. The portion of each plate also seemed less and it took so long for them to refill our beef at the beginning. 

Rough Japanese Wagyu Beef
119 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 Even worse, we were soon given these rough "Japanese Wagyu beef" which were so much worse, almost like those really rough Wagyu we ate at 牛陣! 

Smooth Japanese Wagyu Beef
118 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 After eating 4 portions of rough Japanese Wagyu Beef, they gave us these smooth ones again without any complaint from us. It was so random. And then after a few more portions, they served us rough beef again.....It didn't happen to us last time at 牛涮鍋 when we had Wagyu of really high quality throughout our meal, while we once had even rougher beef throughout our meal at 牛陣...

Pork
75 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 The pork was pretty rough as expected. No more please.

Sukiyaki Soup Base
86 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 We ordered Sukiyaki Soup Base, which was pretty good in the first few rounds making the beef taste so good despite no seasoning! But it turned pretty tasteless very soon.

Sukiyaki Soup Base with Japanese Eggs
79 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 The "5" score was given to the Japanese eggs, which tasted really fresh and delicious! 

Green Sprouts
98 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 Other typical vegetables and noodles were served, just like other shabu shabu places. The most pleasing thing here was these green sprouts, which were really fresh and delicious! We had loads! They were really the highlight of the meal!

Milk ice-cream or frozen yoghurt with toppings
86 瀏覽
0 讚好
0 留言
 They served milk ice-cream or frozen yoghurt in a machine with a lot of toppings including 小麥杯芽
, crispy chocolate cereals, cornflakes, red beans, crispy rice (which was not crispy at all), roe-like yoghurt balls, jellies, chocolates etc. The ice-cream was really smooth while the frozen yoghurt was even better as it was so refreshing and smooth with its slightly sour flavour! I think it went great with 小麥杯芽 and chocolate cereals! Yummy!

Overall, I think:
In terms of beef, 牛涮鍋>牛一>牛陣
In terms of ice-cream, 牛陣 HD ice-cream ~ 牛一 Frozen yoghurt > 牛涮鍋 soft cream (but 牛涮鍋 did have other desserts like cheese cake and puff etc)
In terms of vegetables, 牛一>牛陣>牛涮鍋
In terms of service, 牛涮鍋>牛一>牛陣
In terms of price, 牛涮鍋(most expensive)>牛一>牛陣(cheapest)
Overall, 牛涮鍋>牛一>牛陣 as beef should be the major driving factor after all.

So please make your own choice. Hope you find this commentary helpful 
(以上食評乃用戶個人意見 , 並不代表OpenRice之觀點。)
  • 推介
    已推介
  • 檢舉
13 已推介
    張貼
    評分
    味道
    環境
    服務
    衛生
    抵食
    用餐日期
    2018-05-03
    用餐途徑
    堂食
    人均消費
    $273 (午餐)
    推介美食
    First round of Japanese Wagyu Beef
    Smooth Japanese Wagyu Beef
    Sukiyaki Soup Base with Japanese Eggs
    Green Sprouts
    Milk ice-cream or frozen yoghurt with toppings
    • Frozen Yoghurt
    • Milk Ice-cream